Hailed as the most radical change to planning in over sixty years, the Government’s national planning policy framework published this week has quickly both drawn fire and approval. The National Trust warns of Los-Angeles style urban sprawl, while developers welcome the new pro-development agenda. The Campaign to Protect Rural England predicts “battles against development across the country that will make the public revolt against the forests look like a tea party”. Is it really so radical and will it be a positive improvement? We need a locally-rooted and pro-active planning system that does not hamper positive development and actively encourages good design. We need more housing to meet demand, provide greater choice and create better community services. Replacing thousands of pages of central government policy with fifty pages is welcome. And the central theme – a presumption in favour of ‘sustainable development’ – sounds good. But what does it mean and who defines it? Most importantly, can it be delivered? Sustainable development is defined as encouraging economic development within the framework of promoting ‘healthy communities’, good design and protecting our existing environment. Local authorities are charged with weighing up these issues and forming coherent detailed policy. It’s a tall order, and planners can no longer rely on central government guidelines – it all has to be done locally. There’s the rub: if authorities don’t produce up-to-date local plans, then any development that falls within the framework’s general guidelines will receive planning permission. Is this another way of the Government getting what they want by default and bashing local authorities, or is this a genuine opportunity to address pressing local problems at a local level with our democratically elected councillors – perhaps even to develop useful and positive neighbourhood plans? In principle this is fine, but local authorities lack the resources and skills to properly undertake the plans. Take quality of design. The minister, Greg Clark, says “Our standards of design can be so much higher. We are a nation renowned worldwide for creative excellence, yet, at home, confidence in development itself has been eroded by the too frequent experience of mediocrity”. That’s great, but who will ensure this? It’s good to encourage local design review panels but they will see few schemes and do little to embed design expertise in local government. A successful outcome of the framework needs need properly resourced local government financed by local taxes (as in Holland) rather than central hand-me-downs. Local authorities would be more independent and better able to determine the shape of our towns and countryside. While I concur with the spirit of the new framework, it can’t really tackle the issues effectively with our current system of governance. Anthony Hudson
DESIGN MATTERS: Will The New Planning Changes Make a Difference?
Author / Hudson Architects
Similar Journals

Houses & Trees #2 – ‘Wood-Hoods’, ‘Neighbour-woods’ and a True ‘Forest Village’
April 12, 2022My recent post about houses and trees was part of a long-standing interest in the topic which is at least as old as a thought-experiment called ‘Forest Village’, which I carried out over a decade ago. I come back to it from time to time, and I have recently stumbled across two other projec
Continue reading
FibreBroads Research Project: Explained
July 26, 2024The following illustrative series presents the overall purpose of the FibreBroads research project and our role within it in bite-sized pieces. At Hudson Architects, we take pride in expanding our expertise into research and development. The FibreBroads project aligns with our values, focusing on su
Continue reading
Atlantic Beach Regeneration Competition: Lewis Williams Has Made It To The Finals!
April 21, 2022We are immensely proud of Architectural Assistant Lewis Williams whose submission to the Atlantic Beach Regeneration Competition has been made it to the final round! The competition’s jury anonymously selected three finalists from a very strong field of designs from all over the world. Th
Continue reading